Monday, September 28, 2009

Lobo's essay

For those who might care, I present the first draft of my essay:


The Internet. Arguably the greatest thing man has created. It is an invention that has brought the sum of human experience and wisdom into each and every home. No doubt something to be loved by all. However, I believe that some of America’s greatest minds, namely Emerson, Whitman, and Thoreau would detest and fight against its existence.

Thoreau found the news to be a useless distraction. One that removed people from the area around them and brought their thoughts to faraway lands and to situations they had no power over whatsoever (not that they have much power on their own situations). Thoreau would have hated the Internet for its power to bring news and gossip from around the world to people in a matter of seconds. The Internet manages to connect people to all of the rest of Earth with ease. That’s what it was designed for. The Transcendentalists would have detested such interconnectivity. In an age where even the hobos have cell phones and laptops, where can one go to escape? The answer oddly enough lies within the Internet. While the Internet provides for an unprecedented amount of connection, it also allows for complete anonymity. Emerson said that one must retire from not only society but also from his chamber. This was necessary to escape from ideas other than your own original ones entering your mind. Emerson also said that “A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds.” This leads me to the conclusion that Emerson not only wanted people to retire from their chamber, but also from themselves. The Internet’s total anonymity provides for the perfect way to escape oneself. On anonymous forums it is possible to express and think freely without fear of retribution for what is most probably nonconformity. In addition the immense amounts of different opinions leads to so much variability of what is expressed, coupled with the fact that everyone can add to it that there really is no fear of being too influenced. In every single little forum thread you can find so many conflicting opinions that you can easily build your own from scratch; and from there have an original opinion. So in that regard I say the Transcendentalists are wrong. The Internet does not deprive you in your ability to escape.
Another thing the Transcendentalist would find at fault with the very concept of the Internet is how it removes you from nature. To be on the Internet you must be on a computer and be near a source of bandwidth. These things are almost always found inside is the normal presumption. The Transcendentalists, who believe that nature is akin to God and that nature is that with which me must find a connection to, would loathe this dependency on streaming electrons. However again they would be wrong. While the Internet can easily be seen to deprive one of Nature it is easy to reconnect thanks to the Internet. Even as I type this I can, with a few clicks and a couple of keystrokes, place myself at any point of the globe. A little typing and instantly I can gaze at the forests of Amazon, a few more keystrokes and I find myself in the Sahara, again and I am in the frozen tundra of Siberia. The Transcendentalists couldn’t access this kind of instant nature! They had to hike miles out into the woods to get to nature, and then they were restricted to what little biomes they could visit. The Internet on the other hand allows for me to see the entire world. Furthermore the internet does not deprive one of access to nature. I can easily get a satellite uplink on my computer and go out into the forest, and still have access to both nature and all of human experience and knowledge simultaneously. Not too shabby a deal.

Another issue that the Transcendentalists would have with the Internet is the sheer fact that one can access so much information with such ease. I believe that the Transcendentalists, especially Emerson, would have detested how much knowledge can be gained second hand. Again I find myself to disagree with them. In their time knowledge was spread via paper and word of mouth, thus making knowledge sources subjective was extremely easy. However, now that knowledge can be spread so quickly and, thanks to Wikipedia (lets face it, how often do we use other sources?), it can be edited easily. This of course leads to information having to be much more objective. Objectivity is needed because if everyone is capable of adding what they think about something with anonymity then they can just as easily complain about information being biased. Therefore the information, while received secondhand is in a much more pure form then that which would have been presented to the Transcendentalists. Life is so much easier nowadays.

While the Transcendentalists were very intelligent and were assuredly some of America’s greatest thinkers, their ideas remain unnecessary in the face of the Internet. While their ideas do make for an interesting read, they cannot be put into the context of the internet and hope to hold up. In short, the Internet is awesome, and the Transcendentalists are outdated.



any and all comments appreciated.

Saturday, September 26, 2009

A new idea, a new direction...

I was going to bring Emerson back into our time, and have him make comments on life as we know it today, as many of my classmates were doing, but then I came across a different idea. I wrote about Emerson as talking to me directly, and not really saying anything new, but helping me to see something in a different light. I would post it, but I'm not sure about it yet. There are still somethings that need tweaking. I just thought that I would replenish my earlier post by actually blogging about a solid idea. The assignment says that we need to, in some way make the words relevant to an event in our lives, and as many of you have probably already heard me say, with college around the corner I am finally noticing the beauty of Telluride. This is what I wrote about, Emerson helping me truly see nature. :)

Friday, September 25, 2009

!#$@#$!

In my essay I am going to bring Emerson into the future and see his take on the great 21st century America. he will look at the materialistic items we treasure, the conformity on the everyday scale and the lack of finding true nature as are computer addicted, text messaging, world of war craft playing masses get paler indoors everyday . it will be fun to give his views on the irrelevant objects we cherish and views of people in modern society.

For my essay i'm thinking of writing more from a journal style instead of a formal essay. I havent decided exactly what i'm going to write about but i think i'm going to take a few different points that i've highlighted while reading and discuss not only my opinion on them but how they could relate to the world today. The way I'll be writing this will be similar to the way Abbey wrote 'thoreau and other friends'. I'll have the different 'entries' of this journal dated along the days that we've gotten the different writings we've recieved so far in class and use my annotations to discuss different points. When finished it will basically be my person interpretation of how these points relate to todays world and to myself.

Ideas... Ideas...

So it took me a while to decide what to write about and I'm still keeping an open mind, however, I think the topic for my essay is going to be modern day lifestyles. I'm going to discuss how everything we do and wear and believe in is shaped and based off of something else. Nothing is original anymore since it has most likely already been done. As children, we learn from our parents, teachers, peers, and elders who have learned from the people before them and so on and so forth. With this trickle down of information and traditions, there are only discreet and small changes to the way we do things. I am going to bring Thoreau, Emerson and Whitman all back to life just as E.B. White did and get their opinions and thoughts on being original, and how that does not seem to exist anymore. I am going to criticise the world as we know it through their eyes. With three strongly opinionated authors I feel that this essay will turn out alright.

NO AUTHORITY

“It is easy in the world to live after the world’s opinion; it is easy in solitude to live after our own; but the great man is he who in the midst of the crowd keeps with perfect sweetness the independence of solitude.”

“The sun illuminates only the eye of the man, but shines into the eye and the heart of the child.”

“Who has retained the spirit of infancy even into the era of manhood?”

These are some of the quotes from Emerson that will help me spark more ideas about my essay. I am planning on using a combination of ideas from Emerson to help me et my point across. One of my main ideas will be the stages of growing up and how your mind becomes more brainwashed by the world and the whole system every day. From going to school all the way to watching news, the mind only gets dumber as you grow up. I will present all of this information by a simple scenario of me going to a normal day of school. Then all of the sudden I will have some sort of problem with the authority in my school and I will go crazy. All of the sudden I realize that I have no purpose in following all the kids around in my school and I decide to live a more simple life. Then with out hesitation I pack up every thing I need to live on my own and I start driving. From there I will drive until my tank is empty and then I abandon my car and travel on skies. You must realize that it is the middle of winter and it isn’t exactly the easiest time o lie in the woods. I put the skins on my skies and start skinning up into lizard head pass. I go for a while until I come upon Emerson living in a craze fort built into the snow. From there it goes from two people of a different generation camping together, to two imaginations that are of the same generation, and it becomes more of a sleepover in Emerson’s nature dwelling

Education

To be completely honest, I’m not quite exactly sure what to say in this essay. What I do know is that I will be arguing Emerson’s point of education (through Divinity School and Self-Reliance) with present day examples. I believe that Emerson is trying to expound upon the idea of education as an individual concept. His writings lead me to believe that education or academics are achieved only when one does not conform to the “fathers” complete beliefs “So to regard the young child, the young man requires, no doubt, rare patience: a patience that nothing but faith in the remedial forces of the soul can give... If he has his own vice, he has its correlative virtue. Every mind should be allowed to make its own statement in action, and its balance will appear.” Emerson is not against the idea of formal education, but rather against the idea of the normality of all of the trivial and petty do’s and don’ts. He emphasizes the instances of learning through nature and from what I feel one’s own inclination towards textual meanings “Is it not manifest that our academic institutions should have a wider scope; that they should not be timid and keep the ruts of the last generation, but that wise men thinking for themselves and heartily seeking the good of mankind, and counting the cost of innovation, should dare to arouse the young to a just and heroic life; that the moral nature should be addressed in the school-room, and children should be treated as the high-born candidates of truth and virtue?”