Thursday, September 24, 2009

Transcendentalists and teh interwebz!

For my essay i think i'm going to be looking at the internet, and what the transcendentalists would think of it. Personally i think that while certain parts of it would appeal to them, over all they would hate it. Mostly I think this for a few reasons, the greatest of which is that the internet removes you from nature. Additionally I think that they wouldn't like that everything on the internet is a secondhand source, that pages like Wikipedia prompt conformity. On the other hand I think they would like all the porn. Procreant urges are really easy to satisfy with the internet's help. I think that explaining all that will be the first half of my essay and then in the second half I'm going to defend the internet and say that the Transcendentalists are wrong. I will talk about how things like Google Earth enable people get a view of places that they can't otherwise see, and about how Google Earth can put someone in any part of the world with just a few keystrokes. Also how people can retire to solitude easily on the internet. And while this is a strange and at first glance wrong statement, it is true. I think that when Emerson said that you must retire from society and your chamber, he meant more than just retiring from the opinions and ideas of everyone else but also from yourself. As he said "A foolish constancy is the hobgoblin of little minds". Thus i believe that he wanted people to retire from themselves as well as other's minds. And where better to simultaneously retire from yourself than the completely anonymous internet? On the internet people can express their thoughts freely without worry that "for nonconformity the world will whip you with it's displeasure". Thats the basic idea. I have a few more points that i don't really want to get into, but if anyone has any ideas for other ways in which either the Transcendentalists could attack the internet, or i could defend it, I would appreciate it if you were to share.

3 comments:

  1. Lobo this is a really interesting concept, my one concern is that in the second part of the essay you are going to defend the internet, I feel that this section of the essay could drag on and basically become a list of where they are wrong. If you could figure out an interesting way to do this (like maybe having them explore these truths themselves in some sort of humorous situation) it would strengthen your point whereas it could otherwise become just a list of complaints

    ReplyDelete
  2. Just one thing... when you are on the internet, are you really in a state of solitude? It's just that, to my mind, a lot of the sites on the internet connect you with other people, but because your by yourself physically, you have the illusion of solitude, when really, your surrounded by other people, hords of them. On other sites though, your right, you can be in solitude. You just might want to look at what the Transcendentalists would think of the connecting part of the internet. Just food for thought.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I really like your essay topic Lobo! It's very unique and relates the texts to present day life. I had the same question as Emily though...are your really in solitude? Just something to keep in mind. Over all though...I love your story...I'm looking forward to reading it :)

    ReplyDelete